Few things chill me like sinking into the ocean’s black abyss. I can handle a standard dive, but drop me into a submerged horror scenario and I start analyzing every drip and distant echo. When Still Wakes the Deep dropped its Siren’s Rest expansion, I stripped off my surface gear expecting relentless dread. What I found was a gorgeously moody detour that, despite its ambiance, never quite pulls you under.
The main menu’s static fuzz gives way to the warped corridors of the Beira D, and Siren’s Rest sinks its teeth into your nerves from the start. Every hollow clang and low-frequency hum seems engineered to spike your adrenaline. Flickering lights stretch uneasy shadows over algae-encrusted pipes, and water drips echo like distant knocks on a coffin lid. It’s a masterclass in atmosphere—though that initial thrill fades faster than a dying flashlight.
You step into the wetsuit of Mhairi, a seasoned Scottish saturation diver tasked with recovering lost logs and darker secrets. Her radio chatter with Rob and Hans offers brief camaraderie before the hiss of her rebreather swallows their voices. The voice acting is believable, hinting at frayed nerves beneath the professional veneer. Yet Mhairi’s story arc is so brief that you barely scratch the surface of her character before the next beat hits.
Tracking down data pads, crew journals and underwater relics should fuel paranoia—but it often feels like padding. Crawling through tight crawlspaces hunting pixel-perfect pickups yanks you out of tense set-pieces. Even with oxygen levels ticking down, the gauge never flirts with zero long enough to spark true panic. By the end, your inventory bulges with loot, yet the dread they promise remains largely underexplored.
Key horror beats—an umbilical snapping or a weightless corridor seep—are telegraphed well in advance. Unlike the unpredictable dread of SOMA or the visceral shocks of Dead Space, Siren’s Rest sticks to a playlist of choreographed frights. You’ll see each jump scare coming as reliably as bioluminescent plankton herald a titanic beast.
A lost asset or glitchy UI weeds the tension faster than a leaking hatch. Overlapping dialogue boxes, disappearing hoses and forced reloads pop up at the worst times, breaking the illusion of isolation. Flares are unlimited, undermining resource-scarcity mechanics, and the photo mode seldom affects gameplay beyond capturing eerie snapshots. In a game about dwindling supplies, these missteps aren’t mere nuisances—they weaken the core tension.
Clocking in just under three hours, the DLC hurtles through exposition, character moments and a twist that lands more like a footnote than a payoff. Emotional beats skim the surface, robbed of the space they need to hit home. By the credits, you’re left with a richly detailed setting but a narrative that feels all too fleeting.
If you crave a sensory-heavy descent into claustrophobic darkness—where every drip, groan and echo is dialed to eleven—Siren’s Rest delivers in spades. But if you hunger for emergent scares, a deeper story or tight resource tension, you’ll find this DLC more palate-teaser than main course. It establishes a haunting framework but ultimately leaves you starved for substance.
Siren’s Rest excels in crafting a suffocating atmosphere with its impeccable audio and visuals, yet fumbles in pacing, scare design and narrative depth. It’s a sleek, late-night fright ride that teases a richer sequel—one I’d eagerly book, but hesitate to call a complete experience on its own.
Get access to exclusive strategies, hidden tips, and pro-level insights that we don't share publicly.
Ultimate Reviews Strategy Guide + Weekly Pro Tips