It’s late-way too late. The clock has melted past 2AM, but here I am again, controller in hand, hopelessly caught in Metaphor: ReFantazio’s grasp. The plan was “just one more quest,” like it always is, but I haven’t felt this level of obsession since the first time Persona 4 sunk its teeth into my schedule. I’ll admit it: Metaphor was a game I’d written off, sight unseen, as “Persona but in a pointy-hat fantasy world.” Apparently, that’s exactly the fuel I didn’t know my RPG-loving soul was missing.
For context: I came in suspicious. I’m a dyed-in-the-wool Persona fan, yet JRPGs swimming in capes and crowns rarely get their hooks into me unless there’s a twist. So, here’s the honest story of how Metaphor: ReFantazio not only justified its “spiritual successor” hype, but also overran my nightly routine for two straight weeks and landed itself as my favorite RPG of the year so far.
The first hour in Euchronia was, frankly, overwhelming. There’s an immediate avalanche: animated cutscene, a dead king, a villain with an ego almost as huge as Persona 3’s Tartarus. I remember blinking at my screen, not sure if I’d missed tutorial text somewhere-because the political backdrop here is not subtle or gentle. Louis, the usurper, sets the entire kingdom ablaze with a murder, then vanishes into the mists before I’ve even learned the controls. Awkward, abrupt-it felt more high-stakes Game of Thrones, with a dash of the social strife of Trails of Cold Steel. Honestly, the intro would have lost me if not for Atlus’ flares of confidence: the UI flashes, the distinct musical stabs, and the fact that within ten minutes I was talking to a magical “adjuvant” in my pocket.
BUT—the real hook wasn’t the plot. It was the cast. Persona’s magic works because you get a “found family”—Metaphor doubles down, except they’re outcasts for real, not just quirky teens. By hour three, your protagonist (an honest-to-god outsider to the fantasy gene pool) is meeting Gallin (my favorite—imagine Yosuke with a broadsword and zero impulse control), Mellie (secret-royalty energy, think a less-annoying Yukari), and Hulkenberg, who is like if Persona 5’s Makoto grew up and dropped out of the clergy. Their banter is both sharp and heartbreakingly awkward; you can feel the baggage on their backs. By the end of the prologue, every side glance and stammer had me crowbarred in emotionally.
This is where I was worried most—could you really transplant Persona’s turn-based genius into a kingdom of elves, swords, and magic crystals? About six hours in, the answer was a clear, delighted “yes.” Metaphor’s combat is pure Persona at its core: every battle hinges on reading weaknesses, exploiting status, and making each turn count. But there’s something new—the Archetype system. Instead of just picking Personas, you channel “Archetypes,” which is basically the game’s take on job classes: Knight, Mage, Seeker, and plenty of others that unlock as you play (I actually yelped the first time I discovered the “Trickster”—the nod to Joker from P5 was not subtle, and I loved it).
Every party member can eventually dabble in multiple Archetypes. Managing who’s a beefy tank and who’s a spell-slinging glass cannon is a joy for people who obsessively min-max (guilty). I lost a ridiculous amount of time theorycrafting builds for each palace—er, dungeon—and constantly swapped roles to try and break tricky bosses. The boss fights? Chef’s kiss. There was this one, the “Chimeric Bishop,” that wiped me three times at 11:30 PM because I didn’t bring enough anti-confusion spells. Old-school Atlus, unforgiving and fair: adapt or watch the Game Over screen. This stuff scratched the same itch as digital devil taming in Shin Megami Tensei, but the team mechanics made it warmer, more personal.
Okay, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of what Persona fans crave: relationships. The social system here is rebranded as “Fellowships.” Instead of high-school ranks, you’re deepening connections and unlocking unique side stories (they call them “Chronicles”). My first Fellowship moment genuinely surprised me: console in hand, midnight, I just meant to knock out a short event with Gallin, but it spiraled into a half-hour-long reveal about his backstory and his bitter resentment toward Euchronia’s ruling class. This hit harder than expected—less anime fluff, more character trauma and grit. There’s levity, sure (“let’s go fishing!”), but around every corner, the narrative reminds you that being different here gets you killed or worse. That undercurrent made the cast feel complicated and real. The writing’s not perfect (sometimes, it leans melodramatic), but it’s never as tone-deaf as Persona’s weakest S-Links.
One caveat: the game throws a lot at you in the first 10 hours. The city menus, party customization, item fusion, even a fairytale equivalent of Persona’s “Velvet Room.” It’s intimidating. I recommend spending extra time early on just poking around—because once it all clicks, the game’s sense of freedom is intoxicating. For me, that moment was around hour 12, when I realized I could approach side quests in any order, and that every dungeon was hiding not just loot, but full-on side plots. Some of the best writing was stashed behind optional objectives—if you mainline the campaign, you’re missing the heart of the game.
I played on PC, mid-range rig (RTX 3070, i7-11700F)—rock-solid in most scenes, but there were hiccups. Large cities sometimes dropped below 60fps if I bumped the resolution scaling up (usually after rain or heavy spell effects), but it was rare. The one technical blemish I can’t forgive: the loading stutters between certain fast-travel points. Twice during tense moments, I walked into a new map and the soundtrack hiccupped, which yanked me out of the experience. It’s fixable, but noticeable. Visually, though? Utterly gorgeous. The palette is richer and weirder than Persona’s neon—think lush, painterly fields twisted into strange, haunting dream-forests. The world feels alive and, often, dangerous. The character models looked a little stiff if I zoomed in during dialogue, but the art direction is A-tier.
And the music… whoa. Shoji Meguro’s spirit is all over this soundtrack even if he wasn’t behind every track. There’s more traditional fantasy flourishes, but layered with percussion and synths that scream modern Atlus. The “Victory” jingle was lodged in my skull for days. It’s not just background filler—certain pieces hit hard in boss fights and story beats (the choral theme that hits during Louis’s confrontation? Absolutely spine-tingling).
No Atlus game is perfect, and Metaphor doesn’t break that tradition. Late-game pacing is a slog. Around hour 85-ish (yeah, I really went that long), the campaign throws what I can only call a “padding gauntlet”—a series of fetch quests between major story beats that felt arbitrary. I groaned, I cussed, but I pushed through because by then I wanted to see the end. Also, some dungeons feel indistinguishable visually, which had me literally checking my quest log to remember why I was there. And for all the innovation, a few side characters feel underbaked; not quite as memorable as Persona 4’s loveably weird NPCs. These are nitpicks in a game this big, but they add up.
One thing I should mention: difficulty is real. Even Normal mode made me grind, and there’s an occasional outright cheap enemy ambush (those were, admittedly, mostly my fault for getting reckless with positioning). If you’re here for a breezy, no-stress JRPG, this is not that.
If you’ve ever lost a Saturday night to a Persona game, you’ll feel right at home. It’s not just a re-skin—if anything, it’s a bold experiment that takes the formula and asks, “What happens if our world hates magic, hates outsiders, and nothing is safe?” If you want shorter or lighter RPGs, though, be warned: Metaphor is meaty and not always friendly to casual play. People like me, who thrive on getting lost in big systems and tough battles, will be delighted. If you tap out after too much melodrama or long-winded menus, maybe save this for when you’re ready to commit.
To sum it up: Metaphor: ReFantazio is the first game in years that actually made me lose sleep (and not in a frustration way, thank god). Its highs—emotional party moments, gorgeous settings, crunchy combat—completely outshine its inevitable lows (some pacing issues, and a couple technical hiccups on PC). Rarely does a game make me eager to talk about it with friends right after I finish a play session. If you ever wished Persona would ditch the schoolbags and lean into swords, spells, and messy, politically charged stakes, this is the RPG you’ve been waiting for. I’m already planning a New Game+ run. 9/10 from me.
Get access to exclusive strategies, hidden tips, and pro-level insights that we don't share publicly.
Ultimate Reviews Strategy Guide + Weekly Pro Tips