This is the PS Plus month I’ve been waiting for. Sony just lined up three heavy hitters for Halloween-Silent Hill 2 Remake, Alan Wake 2, and The Last of Us Part II Remastered-leaning hard into tension, narrative, and genuine dread. Quick reality check before the panic downloads: these are “included with your sub,” not free forever, and they’re part of the Game Catalog for Extra/Premium, not the monthly Essential giveaway. With that caveat out of the way, it’s a killer lineup that actually respects your time.
Bloober Team’s remake is the headliner for obvious reasons: the original Silent Hill 2 defined psychological horror for a lot of us. The remake nails the oppressive fog, mournful tone, and that suffocating melancholy the series does so well. Some outlets even went as high as 17/20, and I get why—art direction and audio design are on point, and the town still feels like a character that hates you.
But it’s not a one-to-one nostalgia trip. The over-the-shoulder perspective and modernized combat change the vibe, sometimes for the better (less clunky frustration) and sometimes not (the awkwardness used to be part of the fear). Pacing hiccups and a few animations remind you you’re playing a remake that’s trying to serve two masters: 2001’s fever dream and 2024’s expectations. If you can accept that trade, the emotional punch lands hard—and it’s a perfect October play with headphones and lights off.
Alan Wake 2 is Remedy doubling down on what made Control and the original Wake special: stylish storytelling, reality-bending meta horror, and a light-mechanics-driven combat loop that’s more about dread than power fantasy. The dual-protagonist structure—splitting time between newcomer Saga Anderson and a trapped Alan—lets you bounce between FBI procedural and surreal writer’s purgatory. It’s visually arresting and unapologetically odd, with some of the most memorable set-pieces of the last few years.
On PS5, performance has improved post-launch, and there’s a performance mode if you prioritize responsiveness. Expect chunky downloads and an experience that can be demanding—on hardware and attention spans. Also remember: the DLC (Night Springs and The Lake House) is paid and usually not included with PS Plus. The base campaign stands on its own, but if you fall in love with Remedy’s rabbit hole, budget time and cash accordingly.
Naughty Dog’s remaster sharpens an already razor-edged narrative with PS5 bells and whistles and, crucially, No Return—a roguelike survival mode that finally gives the sublime stealth-combat sandbox room to breathe outside the story’s heavy beats. If the original campaign broke you (emotionally) and you’ve hesitated to revisit, No Return is a great way to enjoy the mechanics without shouldering the full narrative weight every session.
You also get “Lost Levels” with developer commentary, guitar free play, DualSense support, and a suite of accessibility options that’s still best-in-class. One note for owners: the old $10 PS4-to-PS5 upgrade path for the remaster is a separate thing—PS Plus access doesn’t grant permanent ownership.
We’re in a horror renaissance—Resident Evil remakes, Dead Space’s return, and Alan Wake 2’s awards run—and Sony is smartly leaning into that momentum. After PS Plus’s price hike, months like this are exactly how you justify the sub: prestige single-player, no microtransaction traps, heavy on mood and narrative. It also fills a quiet stretch for first-party releases with undeniable “you should play this” experiences that keep PS5s powered on.
PS Plus Extra/Premium’s Halloween selection is the rare drop that delivers real value: three top-tier single-player experiences that respect your time and intelligence. They’re not “free,” and DLC isn’t bundled, but the base games alone are worth a month of your sub. Clear space, dim the lights, and prepare to actually feel something.
Get access to exclusive strategies, hidden tips, and pro-level insights that we don't share publicly.
Ultimate Gaming Strategy Guide + Weekly Pro Tips