Have you ever shelled out full price for what is essentially an empty container? In 2010, Nintendo did just that. To celebrate Mario’s 25th anniversary, the company re-released Super Mario All-Stars on Wii. Sounds great—until you learn the game itself occupies a mere 12MB on a disc that can hold 4.7GB. That’s over 99% unused space. It’s a bold flex from Nintendo, but also, let’s be honest, a cheeky poke at collectors.
On paper, this seems ridiculous. Nintendo took its 1993 SNES compilation—four Mario titles in one—and ported it verbatim to Wii. No HD upgrade, no new modes, not even widescreen support. It was a straight copy-paste of the original ROMs.
Despite this bare-bones approach, Nintendo slapped a €25 price tag on the package—about three times the cost of a standard Virtual Console SNES title at the time.
Okay, so the disc is mostly empty. What else did you get for €25? That’s where the smart packaging comes in. Nintendo knew collectors treasure more than just the code; they crave context and ceremony.
It was an unapologetic exercise in “memory markup”—charging top dollar to package existing digital code inside fancy extras. And yet, gamers lapped it up.
Nintendo has always excelled at mining its past for profit. From the NES Classic to the SNES Mini, every limited-run console sells out in minutes. The 12MB disc was the first time the company applied that retro-wallet strategy to a full-price title. The allure of physically owning a piece of history proved irresistible.
Think about it: while the original ROM files could be emulated or downloaded, the tactile experience of opening a commemorative box, leafing through a booklet, and slotting in a disc had a power that pixels on a screen simply can’t match. It tapped into the same emotional drive that floods collectors when they sight a sealed action figure or a first-edition trading card.
At launch, reactions were split. On one side, dedicated retro fans—and completionists—praised the collectible packaging and the nostalgia trip. They treated the anniversary edition like a shrine piece: something to display on a shelf, not just to play.
On the other side, purists and value-seekers cried foul. “Lazy cash grab,” they snapped on forums. “All we needed was widescreen support or some bonus levels.” Critics argued that the €25 price tag should have bought at least minimal enhancements, not a carbon copy of code that had circulated online for years.
Yet, online debates fizzled out as coast-to-coast sold-out notices rolled in. The “lazy cash grab” had sold out anyway—a testament to the fact that scarcity and FOMO (fear of missing out) can drown out the grumbling.
Slowly, boxed copies began trading hands on auction sites. Prices climbed well above the original €25. Suddenly, what was once a full-price anniversary item became a hot commodity in a secondary market. Sellers touted “factory sealed” and “mint condition,” treating the bundle like fine wine whose value only increased.
From a purely economic standpoint, Nintendo engineered scarcity. By limiting the print run and never offering a digital alternative, the company made the product’s physical scarcity its strongest selling point. It turned a simple re-release into a high-margin collectible.
If playing the game was your only goal, Nintendo Switch Online subscribers have a far cheaper path. For less than the price of a single premium subscription fee, you unlock a library of SNES classics—complete with modern save states, rewind features, and fair pricing.
But digital fails to satisfy the “I was there” thrill. A download icon on your console may offer convenience, but it lacks the heft of a well-designed box, the smell of fresh-printed pages, and the crackle of a CD loading in a stereo. Physical editions tap into a different part of the psyche—one that digital can’t reach, no matter how many extras you bundle in code.
Looking back, the 25th-anniversary stunt foreshadowed a decade of minimal-effort ports commanding premium prices. We saw ports of classic handheld titles on Switch, straightforward compilations with little to no added content, and limited-edition consoles that vanished before most fans could log on to preorder.
It’s maddening for purists who crave fresh ideas. But from a business standpoint, it’s pure genius. Nintendo monetizes its back catalog while keeping development costs low. No new engines, no new assets—just repackaged gold that keeps paying dividends.
Nintendo wasn’t alone in this. Other publishers tried similar moves—brief commemorative re-releases of 16-bit classics, soundtrack vinyl editions, or deluxe art books. Few generated the same level of buzz, though. Many boxed bundles felt more like afterthoughts, lacking the brand power and fan devotion that Mario commands.
That said, Mario’s relic release set a template. If you want collectors to open their wallets, you give them just enough substance to feel special and just enough scarcity to feel panic. The rest is baked in: every gamer knows Mario, and every gamer has a nostalgic chord that can be strummed.
By now, it’s clear the disc’s capacity was never the point. The empty space became part of the story. It was an in-joke to hardcore fans: “Look how much we left unused!” That wink backfired if you were expecting innovation, but it played to a loyal base that would pay for the joke alone.
Nintendo turned emptiness into a feature. They sold the story of legacy—of Mario’s journey from 8-bit sprite to multimedia superstar. The disc’s wasted gigabytes became a symbol of confidence: “We don’t need to fill this—even half our audience will buy it anyway.” And they did.
In hindsight, Super Mario All-Stars on Wii stands as a monument to Nintendo’s faith in its own IP. A 12MB game on a 4.7GB disc is absurd, yet it sold out. It’s a wink to collectors, a middle finger to anyone expecting extra effort, and a savvy reminder that nostalgia is a currency all its own.
Next time you spot a “collector’s edition” with miles of empty disc space or a price tag that makes you choke, ask yourself: are you buying the game, or the story they’re selling? With Nintendo, it’s usually the latter—and they’ve never been better at selling the fiction.
Get access to exclusive strategies, hidden tips, and pro-level insights that we don't share publicly.
Ultimate Gaming Strategy Guide + Weekly Pro Tips